I met a new therapist yesterday. We nearly got off to a bad start when she asked me what my ‘aims and objectives’ were, and my ‘goals and targets’. I had to explain that I was ILL and that I had no control over my ILLNESS otherwise I wouldn’t be, so it was unhelpful to infer that I had. I have a corporate background, so I know where all this guff come from, but I really don’t think it should be part of therapist training. It can be so demoralising to be treated as if we have caused our own illness, and have the power to put it right if we only tried! Anybody else been asked their Goals? If this is becoming commonplace, then it should stop.
My goal is to wake up in the morning. My target is to find my socks and slippers. My objective is to make a coffee and feed the cats. My aim is to get through the day, but I often miss.
I’m not a fan of this kind of doublespeak and not surprised it took you aback. Some people love motivational doublespeak and they even put post-it notes with phrases around the place. Great for some, not for me, I’m too much a skeptic and linguist to swallow such black and white jargon.
I recall you had found a therapist, so if you don’t mind me asking, why do you have a new one?
Oh ho! My fav subject….mid career corporate yukspeak was introduced into services and I became renowned for constantly questioning people’s blether at management/committee this or that meetings….my biggest bug beat was SMART objectives and KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATORS….hey you! These are people we are talking about!!! Same now with all this zoom and telephone interviews, I always insisted on seeing people face to face (except in Covid obvs) home visits if necessary…. I was not particularly popular with the high heid yins as you can imagine. I could understand why Scot Gov wanted to account for budget spending but not at the expense of the service users eh…..I think there might be a campaign for plain speak somewhere. Rant over LOL
It’s not really the start anyone of us would want, mines was similar at the start but I work in child support services so have to at times spout that corporate guff. For me I asked if we could reset and talk like proper people having a talk at a cafe or pub. It actually worked after a few weeks as I steered conversations to more about how I am or not coping and no amount of pseudo intellectualism would help.
Good luck and hope that you get some answers from this.
In 2022 I had a change of Clinical Neuropsychologicst after 4 years. The Neuropsychologicst I was originally with was around my own age at the time, mid fifties. She decided to relocate and I really missed my one to one appointments every two months as I got so much from them, she would even occasionally involve my wife. This lady had written books on brain injuries of all types and often spoke at national conferences. It took over a year to replace her.
My first appointment with her replacement did not go well, especially as I have frontal lobe damage with a gate that is never fully closed. She was in her late twenties possibly early thirties, it was hard to tell as she wore a face mask. About 5 minutes into my appointment she asked me to close my eyes and starting at my head I was to think how it felt and we would work our way down the body. I switched off immediately and stared out the window into the hospital car park as she continued with her eyes closed. When she opened them she asked me how I felt now, “no different, I am just admiring the BMW parked outside.” She then asked me why I didn’t participate. “You think someone with hypervigilance is going to shut their eyes in a strange room with someone they have never met before?” A very bad start, she confessed to not having read through my notes before meeting me.
The following appointments were just as bad, she spoke in a way that smacked of just out of university. Using goals, aims and future targets. All of them for me were just waking up and functioning. I called a halt after eleven appointments and told her honestly that I had no idea what she was trying to achieve as I left every appointment with no idea what she was talking about. It was best that we called it quits.
The difference from the first lady in maturity and how she spoke was light years apart. I suppose it’s just the difference in the way younger people speak and use language nowadays. For me as a grumpy old man it doesn’t belong in any medical situation.
I did wonder at times if my resistance to the “new” language meant I was resistant to change or indeed was ageist, but having pondered, I don’t feel it’s brought us any way forward in human relations/interactions….i think that with a lot of “ tech” too..I am sure there are huge possibilities/positives in most of it….but what if it doesn’t work! In storm Boelo I lost both phone and internet, even my house phone went dead, all returned now but was scary for a day!
I could be stepping into unknown territory here, though it won’t be the first time nor will it be the last time.
Firstly, I think all respondents this this post/thread are not fans of this “corporate yuckspeak” and I include myself in that.
I would like to explore a little bit further, by commenting on what I have seen as two different responses, and perhaps I may have misunderstood something.
As I understand it, @Dexster didn’t like the idea of the goals/objectives and goals/targets approach, whereas @Rups, whilst not being a fan of doublespeak, would nevertheless have responded to the therapist by giving an answer.
It seems to me that if we take the Rupert approach we can still work with the therapist and indeed we might even steer them in the direction we want to go and which would work for us?
I say this because I feel whether we like it or not, it is part of therapist training and so if are to use therapists we would have to accept it or learn to deal with it.
During my working life, I have seen so much nonsense come and go and it’s what I call “flavour of the month” or “jumping on bandwagons”. In most cases, it came and went and I/we just dealt with it until the next thing came along (and it always does).
Can we stop it?
I suspect not because it comes from higher up.
Can we do something about it?
Absolutely.
I have mentioned this before but there were no takers. To do what you are suggesting i.e. to offer service, help and support that the stroke survivor/carer can relate to it has to come from someone who understands it? This is something I see on this forum often. “This forum is the best place to be because people understand your experience because they have been there, done that and got the t-shirt”. New members often comment, they find the forum a breath of fresh air etc. etc. etc.
If you are to see this sort of service/support/approach stop, you have to cause it. You have start offering this service and you have to find people who can provide this service. Because, from where I’m standing, this is the only way it can happen. Sorry to suggest this in this way, but it’s a “business opportunity”.
There are, in my view, a few members of this forum, who have that skills, experience and knowledge to do this, but unless they are of that frame of mind, this will not happen.
I don’t know how many of the members come from a business background and whether they would agree, but this is what I think. Just my mad cap idea or thoughts on the subject.
My apologies if I have caused chaos by taking this thread of the path, but sadly, this is something I am prone to do every now and then, it’s just who I am.
Namaste|
Mad Cap wearing Jim
If my previous post above, doesn’t make sense or work, then would this post from Bobbi work?
I think there could be something in that - worth exploring, me thinks!
Not necessarily, I knocked back my first therapist because she produced one of her old uni books and started to read from it. The key with therapists is finding the right fit and no one should feel pressured to stay with someone who can’t read between the lines. I’m fortunate my therapist engages with me in a way that makes me feel comfortable in being as honest as reasonably possible. It’s important to be equals, a therapist is not necessarily someone who has their mental health in order and any therapist that pretends to have it all sorted, I would be wary of.
Guilty as charged m’lud! Guilty as charge!
I think all therapists have been taught this but rather than being irked by it I used it as an opportunity to tell them what I wanted to achieve. That may be something small or something much larger. Once they knew what I was hoping for they could target the therapy in the right way. As an example I wanted to return to work so they worked on things that would help me achieve that. You might want to be able to move your fingers or hold a fork, walk a mile or perhaps put your socks on. They’re all things they can help you work towards.
I appreciate having a stroke is something none of us wanted to go through but we had our strokes & have to find a way to rebuild our lives again…whatever that may look like for you.
For me, I just used their words and turned it into something useful for me.
It’s in the NICE guidelines on stroke rehabilitation so it’s not going to stop any time soon. I think I understand the intention, but the terminology seems very patronising to me. The guidelines also say that patients can choose to decline to set goals, but also say
1.1.8 Once the person has left hospital after having a stroke, continue their care and rehabilitation for as long as it continues to help them achieve their treatment goals.
So if you want any meaningful rehabilitation then it looks like goals are a necessary evil.
Very well explained Ann. You have absolutely “nailed it” to use corporate speak ![]()
I think this is it in a nutshell and it goes nicely with what Paul says in the closing sentence of his response.
It really does come down to this.
Sometimes we just have to learn by the rules when we are not the ones making the rules, but we need to play the game.
Well done @Dexster for creating a very interesting, relevant and most helpful discussion. This is what this forum is about is it not?
Indeed, well done all who participated.
I think we can be overwhelmed in the first few months of recovery. The need to live or just survive we don’t have much control over.
Here is the important part for me, we get invited to attend appointments regarding our health and wellbeing. I receive that invitation for very good reasons. I refuse to listen to any waffle or practices that will not improve my daily life while eating up precious appointment time. The appointment is about me no-one else, not the person hosting me, my experiences nobody else, or someone perceiving what I think or how I act. Listening seems to be a failure in younger people.
I’m not an experiment or a subject for what they have read in medical books. “This is my appointment for my benefit.” Yes I have said it out loud on only one occasion, but I’ve thought it on a few more.
I think this post has made me grumpier than I realised ![]()
I was asked my goals when i was on a hoist and I told them to walk again. I think its good to know what you want so that they work towards your goal. Yes, I was on a hoist and it feels dar fetched but they knew what I wanted and they made me walk. Do no sweat it most of the therapists ask as a guideline to work towards.
Do not sweat it I mean to say. Sorry for the typing error.
I think differently, I think the skill of listening is a difficult one and affect all ages. I tend to think the young are brilliant, and I listen to my yoof as much as possible
I don’t prescribe to the zeitgeist of age, I think it a misnomer or past glories, and I think that it misreprents trials and tribulations of everyone who come after us as a generation.
Now I am out of the corporate world, words are my job (I’m a writer) so words are important to me, and so is precison in their use. The goals and targets thing indicates that the person who is ILL has control over their healing process - which is patently absurd. If we had that control, we wouldn’t be ill. The implication is that we aren’t trying hard enough to recover. None of us needs this demoralising perspective - we’d all like to be as we were before the stroke. It isn’t a GOAL because we can’t work towards achieving it. Implying that we can puts the illness firmly in the category of something we have done to ourselves, and it’s our fault if we haven’t recovered because that is our GOAL. So IMO the term is destructive and demoralising - I for one and I suspect most of us don’t need our morale destroyed by a clumsy set of terms that tell us we have brought this on ourselves and have the ability to improve if only we TRIED.
It seems this topic is quite emotive. I am neither a writer nor in the corporate world and alas, English is not my mother tongue. I say this because this then “gives me permission” to say what I am about to say. I am totally unable to relate to what is being said about GOALS and TARGETS and how use of these terms is destroying moral.
I also don’t agree (or understand as per my understanding of the English language) how goals and targets indicate the person who is ill has control over their healing process, though maybe it does, just that I don’t understand it that way.
I also don’t understand how setting a GOAL implies the illness is firmly placed in the category of something we have done to ourselves, and it’s our fault that we haven’t recovered because that is our GOAL.
In an effort to try to understand how this terminology is viewed by the members of this forum, I did a search using the word GOAL. The search has returned 100+ results and so clearly this is a term much used in discussions. I then skimmed through these and in the main I didn’t find them to be seen as demoralising or accusative.
I found that interesting and so I added the word ACHIEVED and searched for “GOAL ACHIEVED” and this resulted in 50+ results
Again, I skimmed through these posts and found members describing how they had set goals and achieved their goals as part of their recovery.
I now wonder whether this is now just one of those things where “we should agree to disagree” and “if it works for you, do it, if not, don’t”?
As I said, I am not a wordsmith or a linguist and I often struggle to understand the intended meaning of something someone says and I myself have been known to be misunderstood.
Fascinating discussion and I am sure more posts will be added to the 100+ that already exist on corporate yuckspeaks.
Namaste|
This is spot on. It assumes the stroke survivor has agency over their desired outcomes. It also is a weighty word, trying to conceive possible goals or outcomes from a condition that often doesn’t allow the luxury of a future self in the mind’s eye is exhausting and not immediate to the survivor’s emotional and cognitive needs.

